Review for Meadowbrook At Clayton: Is It a Hidden Gem? by Nancy Stempin (September 25, 2024)
Review Comments
A lot of good contextual data; however, the author should consider tying it to the financial tables at the end of the case sooner to help the reader conceptualize the story and provide a better tie-in. The linkage with the learning objectives could be tighter. The authors should consider removing depreciation from LO1. Business plans should be prospective. What has been provided is retrospective, so either provide additional data, such as market/industry growth data, or consider removing LO5. Reflect any changes from the case in the teaching note and consider adding theory to support business analytics (Q3,4), SWOT(Q5), marketing methods(Q6,7),
A lot of good contextual data; however, the author should consider tying it to the financial tables at the end of the case sooner to help the reader conceptualize the story and provide a better tie-in. The linkage with the learning objectives could be tighter. The authors should consider removing depreciation from LO1. Business plans should be prospective. What has been provided is retrospective, so either provide additional data, such as market/industry growth data, or consider removing LO5. Reflect any changes from the case in the teaching note and consider adding theory to support business analytics (Q3,4), SWOT(Q5), marketing methods(Q6,7),